Sunday, October 11, 2009

Cyberfeminism Inersects Writing Research: Studies in Digital Rhetoric

Hocks, Mary.  "“Cyberfeminism Intersects Writing Reseach: Studies in Digital Rhetoric." Webbing Cyberfeminist Practice: Communities, Pedagogies, and Social Action. Kristine Blair, Radhika Gajjalaand, Christine Tulley. Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press, 2008. 235-253.

Mary Hocks’ “Cyberfeminism Intersects Writing Reseach: Studies in Digital Rhetoric” is a discussion of the ways in which cyberfeminism can be integrated in the classroom through various assignments involving technology, and also discusses issues and concerns related to digital rhetoric and opportunities for further research and study in these fields. The article begins with Hocks’ discussion of cyberfeminism, including the history of the term, and her discussion of digital rhetoric and what this term encompasses. Hocks discusses cyberfeminist postmodernism and the ways in which we, as instructors and practitioners of cyberfeminism must understand that “cyberfeminism can also reproduce the White, middle-class feminism that has dominated academia since the second wave” (236). Hocks also discusses the ways in which digital rhetoric is studied by scholars in terms of classrooms and “virtual spaces on the Web” (237). Again, throughout her article, through a discussion of her own new media projects and class syllabi (as well as others’ class syllabi), Hocks links cyberfeminism, digital rhetoric, and the practice and teaching of these topics in the classroom, while making an important point about what cyberfeminism and cyberfeminist approaches must do: “To be done well, cyberfeminist practice must advocate for gendered and other embodied identities in a politically committed way that creates progressive change” (237).


I found this article enlightening in many levels, from Hocks’ discussion of the definition and evolution of terms like cyberfeminism and digital rhetoric, to her discussion of taking a cyberfeminist approach to a class that discussed feminism and technology. I feel that this article is important to my research project for several reasons. First, as I have continued to research online communities, I continuously become more interested in the ways that gender works within these communities. Additionally, I would certainly consider myself a cyberfeminist as well as a feminist pedagogue (perhaps a cyberfeminist pedagogue). I am still learning more about the issues surrounding cyberfeminism in terms of rhetoric, usability, and design. I have decided to focus my project on online communities more on gender, race, and multiculturalism, and I plan to take more usability and design research into account. For these reasons, Hocks’ article is extremely interesting and is applicable to my project from a feminist perspective.

Is N E 1 There? Designing and Building Community Within/Across Classrooms and Institutions

Fore, Melissa, Margaret M. Strain, and Kara Moloney. “Is N E 1 There? Designing and Building Community Within/Across Classrooms and Institutions.” Webbing Cyberfeminist Practice: Communities, Pedagogies, and Social Action. Kristine Blair, Radhika Gajjalaand, Christine Tulley. Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press, 2008. 185-206.


This article is an account of a research project regarding online communities undertaken by three researchers at two different institutions. In order to conduct their study, Strain, Fore, and Moloney designed a six-week writing unit in their classes “that combined selected essays on electronic communications to contextualize our focus on community-building and inform the correspondence among the students” (187). The researchers asked such questions of their students as how they defined community, how community can exist amongst people who may never meet, and how they conceptualized terms like “cyberself” and “cyberidentities.” Beyond what they learned about students’ ideas regarding such topics, the researchers also discuss the community-building that took place through a variety of face-to-face and electronic communications amongst the three researchers themselves.

This article is interesting and highly relevant to my exploration of electronic pedagogy as it relates to writing and community-building in online classrooms. The most useful components of this article include the discussion of this study as an example of feminist research methods (something in which I am very interested) and the responses of the students in question. The least useful component of this article is the fact that it seems to focus so much more on the community-building and problems of the group of researchers than it does on the students. I would not necessarily argue that this article delivers what the title seems to promise: useful information regarding building and designing community in the classrooms. At least it would seem that information along these lines is more than a little eclipsed by the authors’ accounts of their own group dynamics. Most pertinent to my project is this articles discussion of the following: the way in which our use of technology is not neutral and is dependent on the idea that “users import standards of communication established in offline forums” (193); the “flux” of “public use and perceptions about the possibilities of online communication and community” (193); and the qualities students identified as most important for creating a virtual community: trust, shared goals, communication, and proximity” (193). Usefully I think, one of the authors’ final comments on the conclusions reached through their study is as follows:

Only human commitment can bring [community] about. And here feminist practices can inform our Web-based teaching and research. For it is in these relatively new forums that we are classed to make explicit to our students and to ourselves the hidden, the tacit, the as-yet-unaccounted-for qualities that enhance and hinder human community in cyberspace. (199)

I think this quotation best sums up the pertinence of this article to my investigation and also the opportunities for exploration related to this topic. Again, I feel that more of a discussion of the study and the student responses themselves would have been useful, but, overall, I find this article very valuable to my project.

 

Online Communities, Self-Silencing, and Lost Rhetorical Spaces

Kinney, Kelly. "Online Communities, Self-Silencing, and Lost Rhetorical Spaces." Kairos. 6.1. 2001. http://english.ttu.edu/Kairos/6.1/binder.html?coverweb/kinney/index.html
(25 September 2009).

Kelly Kenney’s article discusses the ways in which “feminist notions of community can open rhetorical spaces for women to speak and be heard” (Screen 1). She also discusses the ways in which technology has open up new opportunities for women and others to contribute in the online classroom; at the same time, Kinney cautions online instructors about reinscribing traditional hierarchies in the classroom. She suggests that the instructor must initiate and teach a new approach to community and collaboration in the classroom. She presents her ideas through the discussion of a student electronic list, “[complicating] conceptions of community and discourse practice in the use of computer-mediated discussion groups” (Screen 1). Kinney looks at gender and discusses gendered responses in a forum that boasted a 4:1 female-to-male ratio, something she claims makes her study unique.

Kinney’s assertion roughly half-way through her article that, “While student-centered pedagogies have helped to change the shape of traditional classroom discussions, some still are guided by masculine conceptions of dialogue and community” really hit home for me (Screen 2). As someone who approaches pedagogy from a feminist and collaborative standpoint, I hate to think that I may be perpetuating traditionally masculine forms of communication and relationships and ignoring other forms. In this sense, I find Kinney’s article enlightening and educational. Kinney critiques collaborative pedagogy along the lines that it promotes a linear, singular way of approaching problems, something that is hierarchical and masculine. It does not allow for multiple voices one consensus has been reached. I am familiar with this argument against collaborative pedagogy, and also the argument that we should be more accepting of conflict within the classroom instead of consensus, an assertion that necessarily calls the role of the instructor and his or her authority into question, another issue not directly taken up by Kinney, which raises interesting questions about gender and the classroom. Also interesting is Kinney’s assertion that the masculine way of communicating prevalent in the list is carried over by women used to traditional classroom dynamics. This argument has an interesting connection to “The Anthropology of Online Communities” which also states that we negotiate online communal spaces in basically the same way we negotiate traditional communal spaces, again a testament to the interdisciplinary nature of this topic.

Another particularly useful and interesting point of Kinney’s is that the forum actually began by presenting more typical female methods of communication, but ended up presenting an adversarial male/hierarchal tone that alienated some female participants. I have noted this in our own ENGL 8121 online forum, and I find this interesting to my exploration of the topic of community in the online classroom. Additionally, I believe the phenomenon Kinney discusses in terms of the tone of the forum is an interesting one pertinent to the Strain, Fore, and Moloney article, as well as to the Black article: gender was largely minimized or left out of these discussions of community, save for a discussion of feminist research methods in Strain, Fore, and Moloney. I am probably most interested in Kinney’s article of all the sources I have read as I believe her discussion of cooperation as an alternative to collaboration is one that offers an interesting link to electronic pedagogy itself. It also presents a further analysis of opportunities for postmodern pedagogy in the online classroom. If anything, I wish Kinney had discussed in more detail typical male and typical female methods of communication for those of us who are still becoming familiar with the literature on this topic.

The Anthropology of Online Communities

Peterson, Leighton and Samuel M. Wilson. “The Anthropology of Online Communities.” Annual Review of Anthropology. 31. (2002):  449-67.


In this article, researchers discuss the nature of the Internet as it relates to community and user relations. They indicate that this is a topic relevant to the field of anthropology that has not received much attention in the past. Additionally, the authors contend that the Internet has not radically changed the way community is established amongst human beings. Like most technologies, the authors conclude that the Internet is a cultural product and that it is constituted through language. The authors also argue that there are many opportunities for research upon this topic within the field of anthropology and other fields. The questions the authors are working from are as follows: “How have scholars’ approached online communities and online communication in general? Is the concept of community itself misleading? How are issues of power and access manifested in this arena?” (449). The authors also contend that missing from research and discussions of new media “is the link between historically constituted sociocultural practices within and outside of mediated communication and the language practices, social interactions, and ideologies of technology that emerge from new information and communication technologies” (453).

It may initially seem unusual to consult an anthropological article for the purposes of this project, but it is pertinent in as much as we must understand the aspects of community shaped by the use of the Internet before we work to identify community-building aspects specific to the online classroom. I would argue that this is an interdisciplinary conversation in which the perspectives of those outside the field of Composition and Rhetoric can only add to the interesting and complex questions relevant to such a conversation. This article interests me and is relevant to my investigation of the way community is shaped through language and writing in an online classroom. For example, the authors state:

Such an approach involves bringing research back from cyberspace and virtual reality into geographical, social spaces, to address a variety of issues such as the ways in which new participants are socialized into online practices; how gendered and racialized identities are negotiated, reproduced, and indexed in online interactions; and how Internet and computing practices are becoming normalized or institutionalized in a variety of contexts. (453-4)

The question of how participants are socialized into online practices holds interesting implications for the study of online communities within the online classroom. Additionally, the question of how gendered and racialized identities are negotiated, reproduced, and indexed in online interactions is particularly relevant to the discussion of electronic communications as inherently postmodern, a connection that leaves much room for exploration along the lines of a discussion of an electronic pedagogy. The normalization and institutionalization of Internet and computing practices also offers a opportunity for investigation in light of concerns regarding accessibility. This article is useful for the questions it raises and the conversations it attempts to begin.

 
Powazek, Derek. M. Design for Community. Indianapolis: New Riders, 2002.


Powazek’s book Design for Community is a look inside community-building from a more mainstream perspective. The book discusses the tools needed for a community to form. Powazek raises such questions as “How do you present a discussion system that encourages friendly conversation? How does color influence the tone of conversation? Should there be fewer barriers to entry in a site with community features, or more? How can the community police itself?” (xxiv). Questions like these serve as a jumping off place for Powazek, who also argues an often-overlooked (or understated point): “The medium this communication takes place in is virtual, but the connections themselves are real, intimate, and indeed revolutionary” (xxi). Powazek often takes a rhetorical approach, asking readers to consider audience and purpose before all else. He also instructs community designers not to call their sites community: instead, Powazek argues, if the appropriate tools are provided, the users themselves will be the ones to provide such a moniker.

Powazek also considers visual rhetoric and visual design in his book, discussing matters such a readability, simplicity, color choice, shapes, patterns, photos, and illustrations. He also discusses how one can choose to power a community, a subject most appropriate for general, more mainstream community designers, not necessarily instructors. Interestingly, Powazek devotes an entire chapter of his book to policing and policies, a topic that has interesting implications for managing one’s online classroom and also raises questions, again, about the authority and role of the instructor in an online classroom. Powazek’s discussion of the intimacy of the visual and barriers to entry also raise interesting points in light of a discussion of the online classroom community: barriers to entry, as discussed in DePaw and Lettner-Rust’s “Mediating Power” article, may not be readily apparent to an instructor and may be the product of an administration, a course designer, or the design interface itself. Like most articles and books specifically discussing online community in the online classroom, Powazek discusses the significance of e-mail and immediacy as well. Powazek also takes up such interesting topics (particularly in light of postmodern pedagogy) as gaming, role-playing, and identity shifting in the online community.

As a consultant and someone who has worked on building community on the Web basically since its inception, Powazek’s discussion of the techniques needed to build a successful online community is quite useful. It is important to note that this book is directed at more of a mainstream audience who will likely be engaged in designing communities for a specific group of non-students. The reason I feel strongly this text is useful to my project is because, like many instructors and English teachers, I still consider myself somewhat of a digital immigrant. This book does not discuss the technical side of building community, nor does it discuss how to build sites or chat rooms or anything of the like. Instead, the book focuses on strengthening the intuition of the person attempting to foster the online community, offering, from a design perspective, specific information regarding the tools users need to participate in community-building. In this way, the book manages to subvert the traditional power dynamic associated with a community designer (in my case, and online instructor) and a community member (again, in my case, a student), suggesting that communities are, in fact, built by the members themselves when they are given the proper tools. I think this is an interesting opportunity for research, specifically in postmodern and electronic pedagogies.

Additionally, online instructors frequently have very little (or no) training in design. I think this is a shame, as their choices and the way they organize information in an online class can shape the learning experience and reify ideology. It is useful to take a look outside the information regarding the design of the online classroom from a purely academic approach and consider the basics of design from a more mainstream approach which has stood the test of time. After all, it was the success of online communities at large on the Internet that prompted the belief that we could build online classrooms that offered the same type of learning experience offered in the traditional classroom. Powazek also includes interviews with Howard Rheingold and other big names in the study of online community. The book is smart, streamlined, appealing, and readable, a useful text for someone wanting to understand more about the ideas that undergird community design, whether for the virtual classroom or the general online community.